(404: Witty Comment Not Found)
Welcome to the Stubsack, your first port of call for learning fresh Awful you’ll near-instantly regret.
Any awful.systems sub may be subsneered in this subthread, techtakes or no.
If your sneer seems higher quality than you thought, feel free to cut’n’paste it into its own post — there’s no quota for posting and the bar really isn’t that high.
The post Xitter web has spawned soo many “esoteric” right wing freaks, but there’s no appropriate sneer-space for them. I’m talking redscare-ish, reality challenged “culture critics” who write about everything but understand nothing. I’m talking about reply-guys who make the same 6 tweets about the same 3 subjects. They’re inescapable at this point, yet I don’t see them mocked (as much as they should be)
Like, there was one dude a while back who insisted that women couldn’t be surgeons because they didn’t believe in the moon or in stars? I think each and every one of these guys is uniquely fucked up and if I can’t escape them, I would love to sneer at them.
(Credit and/or blame to David Gerard for starting this.)


Another good critique of FOSS has come across my eyes:
(Recommend checking the full thread, its solid)
I’ve long had the notion, that what I actually like about FOSS (and not all of it) is that it is genuinely intended to work in my interest.
Where FOSS wins in leaps and bounds is the complete absence of licence activation. Licence managers are always 50 times worse than the software they gatekeep, and you get to pay for the privilege of wrangling it. I once ran a cracked version of a commercial software because it was easier than messing with the licensing I was entitled to.
That’s definitely a nice bonus. Could you imagine writing another layer in your workflow automation, because your container needs to be assured you are licensed to run it? I’ve seen shit like that. Couldn’t be me…
The second post in the thread is a great distillation and thesis statement: https://hachyderm.io/@dalias/117635183290482925
I was thinking about this last night. From an end-user perspective, for example, subsystem-specific text configuration files in a top-level /etc directory and dotfiles in the user home directory are less opaque than the Windows Registry. But they are still non-obvious, non-standardized, something you have to spend time wrapping your head around that doesn’t necessarily offer skill transfer to anything else. The movement, such as it is, stood on pride that we had achieved a freely-available replica of something that was expensive, resource-heavy proprietary software in the 1980s, and never moved on from that. Backslid, even. What are we doing here?
I think a lot of the difference is in how the windows registry hides the opacity somewhere that most users will never actually look for it. Like, for a non-technical user it had may as well not exist, while for that same user a Linux system had may as well have a great big door labeled /etc/ with a “do not enter” sign in great big letters. Except then you want the system to do something different and now you need to enter it and pray that your guide to the arcane secrets is right and won’t just break something somewhere else.
Not sure I agree. Being able to modify software leads to people being able to use software which doesn’t have harmful aspects.
You don’t have to understand a linux to just download fedora and abruptly escape surveillance. Or like download a list of adservers and software to route requests to 0.0.0.0
I think that a historical analysis explains the conflict pretty neatly. FOSS came into being among hippy-adjacent computer professionals and hobbyists at a time when those people were a much larger share of the people using computers. Even if you were just looking to dick around playing games on the family computer, simply doing that required a degree of relative technical sophistication. The culture was still more heavily impacted by the academic hackers of previous eras and it was assumed that using a computer with even a functional level of proficiency was always going to require a level of famiarity with how it works and what’s going on ‘under the hood’ that would allow and encourage users to write and customize their own software, and being prevented from doing so by corporate fiat was antithetical to the future of computers as a whole.
Instead, as was arguably predictable, people wanted to take advantage of the power of digital computers without needing to establish and maintain a whole catalog of specialist knowledge and skills. The technology increasingly was designed to mold itself around the user rather than demanding the casual user meet it halfway. UI/UX design started taking a more central position compared to architecture and software design principles, and the increasing speed and availability of internet connectivity allowed for applications to be directly centralized through a client-server model. In the dark ages your terminal connected to a mainframe because the hardware and infrastructure required centralization. The internet re-centralized largely because users wanted to offload as much of the technical and mental workload away from themselves as they could. I think the FOSS true believers usually frame this as a corporate conspiracy against the user, but for the average user this wasn’t an abdication of power and skills - they didn’t have the skills or power in the first place, and didn’t want them. Instead they were allowed to continue focusing on their own shit without having to become computer people.
This is what leads us to the current situation where the most organized and impactful group of people opposing the current oligarchic dynamic that increasingly dominates not just the domain of computing but the global economy as a whole are focused on a set of specialist concerns that are at best orthogonal to the problems most people have with the current system. Their proposed solutions are also directly opposed to the part of the current system that most other people actually find positive. That disconnect is very easily weaponized by the beneficiaries of the current ecosystem to minimize the degree to which the FOSS crowd can advance their goals and to minimize everyone else’s will to find and implement an alternative.
I don’t have a solution here, but I fully agree that the four freedoms of FOSS are not adequate or even necessarily appropriate.
A potential solution – or at least a way forward – would require heavy state involvement.
State-backed organizations could provide free/cheap centralized services for basic application categories, which would become a default as schools and many public orgs would adopt them. Keeping it focused on user freedom rather than surveillance would require ongoing political effort.
Other areas could be subjected to draconian regulation to enforce interoperability and protection from dark patterns. This would require auditable source code and probably developers with watchdog duties embedded in developer teams. (I’ve seen a lawyer sketch out how the EU could do this.)
That would require FLOSS advocates to be both able to make a coherent case and move the needly politically to implement it.
I don’t think we would be talking about FLOSS advocacy any more. We would be talking about socialism, taking some pointers from FLOSS to implement it.